Tucked into the tranquil heights of Hilltop, Prue’s House is more than a restored Panabode cabin—it’s part of a larger story of land preserved for generations. Overlooking an open meadow with access to the Grand Forest trails, the cabin offers a unique space where community, conservation, and connection come together.
At 9600 Mandus Olson Rd., Prue’s House spans 1,000 square feet and can host up to 40 guests. Inside, the main room features hardwood floors, expansive picture windows, and a gas fireplace. Two smaller rooms, a fully ADA-accessible restroom, and a galley kitchen with sink, refrigerator, and counter space round out the amenities. (Please note: no stove or oven.)
Yet what makes this place special goes beyond its walls. In 2011, the Bainbridge Island Land Trust, Parks & Recreation District, and community donors came together to protect the 36-acre Hilltop property, ensuring it would remain open space forever. This landmark conservation effort linked the Grand Forest east and west, creating a 540-acre corridor of meadow and woodland in the island’s core. Prue’s House—once owned by local resident Prue Trudgian—was restored as part of that preservation effort, transforming a private cabin into a public gathering place.
Today, Prue’s House serves as a venue for small retreats, workshops, celebrations, and meetings. Guests enjoy the warmth of the fireplace, sweeping meadow views, and nearby trails just steps away. It’s a place that invites reflection and fellowship, shaped by the quiet beauty of its setting.
Access & Parking: Vehicle entry is from the New Brooklyn side of Mandus Olson Road NE. Parking is limited at the cabin, with additional parking available at the nearby barn.
Prue’s House isn’t just a rental—it’s a doorway into Bainbridge Island’s ongoing story of stewardship and community.